Vote #66073
完了Add cancel button during edition of the wiki
0%
説明
Lack of cancel button during edition of wiki page is very confusing.
Should I use back button? Or where should I click to avoid disaster?
journals
To tell the truth there is a lot of places in Redmine, where users suffer for lack the *cancel* or *back to ...* buttons.
Such a lack is a serious usability issue.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I agree that having a *Cancel* button when editing an issue or wiki page would be nice for users. I generally refresh my browser if I think I have messed something up, but that seems a tad clunky. Some of my users have expressed an expectation of seeing Cancel too.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
+1 for every form that has Ok/Submit button. It should have Cancel button also. While editing this comment, I cannot but finish editing because there's no Cancel button. ;)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
As I see it the main problem with Cancel button is to know were exactly to return to.
Attached suggested patch for "New issue" cancel button ,in this particular case ,
hitting cancel will get you "back" to "issues" which is what for my opinion is the most
likely what the user expects.
Again ,since the New issue is a tab ,were exactly do you redirect the user on Cancel?
Another possible option is to create a Clear button ,not the Cancel one.
The patch is against 1.2.0 stable.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Please don't set assignee.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Sorry.
Etienne Massip wrote:
> Please don't set assignee.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
There are some places that is really very difficult to know what to do on the cancel event, but there are others that is very easy.
Why not to solve this in parts ?
First solve the easy ones ? Like
* Issue update
* Wiki edit
* Others ?
Others more difficult we can leave to solve in future.
+1
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
There's no special difficulty about where to go back in those cases I think. A back url mechanism as in other places in Redmine would be ok.
Some thoughts:
* the difficulty is mainly UI: in "New Issue" we already have 2 buttons and one link, adding an other can add some confusion ; maybe throw it on the right side ?
* the previous button is always ok in Redmine ; I know there are a lot of apps out there that are still in the 90s and horribly break when using Previous/Next buttons, but Redmine is not one of them, there are clean redirects after form submissions so Previous/Next could only lead you to safe actions
* @Evgeny: thanks for your patch but I think we should do a simple link ; going with a button on the create action is semantically incorrect I think, and it's dangerous (if we break our check, we submit the form whereas we didn't want to)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I wrote a patch to add cancel button on wiki edit view.
I think the view should have cancel button for consistency of operation, because issue edit view on Redmine 2.6.1 and later has cancel button (#18051).
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Updated the patch.
Move to a parent page when cancel is clicked if the page is new page.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Cancel link added to wiki edit in r14734.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Our users have requested a cancel link for new issues and news as well. Could this be implemented in 3.4.0? The target could be the previous page as already suggested above.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
JW Fuchs wrote:
> Our users have requested a cancel link for new issues and news as well. Could this be implemented in 3.4.0? The target could be the previous page as already suggested above.
Please create new issues.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Toshi MARUYAMA wrote:
> JW Fuchs wrote:
> > Our users have requested a cancel link for new issues and news as well. Could this be implemented in 3.4.0? The target could be the previous page as already suggested above.
>
> Please create new issues.
Thanks, #23555 created
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
related_issues
duplicates,Closed,20828,Cancel button on wiki edit view
duplicates,Closed,1720,Back button in Wiki